.png)
Article by Lucy Mokua
Rural education in the United States faces unique challenges and opportunities significantly shaped by disparities in funding, access to advanced coursework, and extracurricular activities. While rural schools often provide smaller class sizes and tight-knit community environments that many educators and students find rewarding, they also contend with financial constraints, limited professional development opportunities, and social isolation. These issues impact not only the recruitment and retention of qualified teachers but also the quality and breadth of educational experiences available to students.Â
Teacher Recruitment and Turn-over
The funding disparities have a profound impact on the quality of education in rural areas. One critical aspect is the challenge of attracting and retaining high-quality teachers. Rural schools typically offer lower salaries compared to their urban and suburban counterparts, making it difficult to compete for talented educators. For instance, Community ISD, a modest 2,000-student district in a farming and ranching area north of Dallas, Texas, experienced a significant teacher turnover two years ago with about a third of its teachers leaving due to low salaries. Community ISD had a starting pay of about $39,000, but other schools in the metroplex were beginning at about $52,000. While usually some of the differences in salary can be attributed to the lower cost of living in rural areas, this disparity still poses a challenge. Lower salaries make it difficult for teachers to afford travel, shopping, and other activities outside their immediate area, and can hinder their ability to save for the future.
The financial discrepancy between rural and non-rural areas is compounded by limited professional development opportunities and career advancement prospects in rural settings. Not only are there fewer positions in rural areas but these areas also have limited accessibility to professional development events that are usually held in urban areas, making attempting to climb the career ladder costly and time-consuming for rural educators. As a result, many teachers opt to work in more affluent districts where compensation and career growth potential are more favorable. This trend not only exacerbates the shortage of qualified educators in rural areas but also perpetuates the cycle of educational inequity between rural and urban districts.
Moreover, on the personal side of things, the social isolation often associated with rural areas can further exacerbate the teacher recruitment issue. The geographical remoteness of many rural communities makes them less attractive to prospective teachers, particularly those fresh out of college and accustomed to urban amenities and social networks. For the educators who take on a job in a rural district, the lack of community infrastructure and recreational opportunities can deter them from committing to long-term careers in rural schools.
Coursework and Extracurriculars
The lack of teachers in rural schools leads to significant challenges in providing diverse and advanced coursework, as well as a breadth of extracurricular activities. While nearly 90% of non-rural schools offer advanced placement (AP) courses and a wide range of academic options, only about 50% of rural schools can provide similar opportunities due to staffing shortages and limited resources. The scarcity of qualified educators capable of teaching specialized subjects such as AP courses or advanced STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) topics restricts the academic pathways available to rural students. This disparity not only limits their access to rigorous academic challenges but also hinders their ability to compete on equal footing with peers from more affluent districts in college admissions and future career opportunities.
The gap in access to advanced coursework between rural and non-rural schools is exacerbated by differences in technology infrastructure. Rural students are less likely to have reliable internet access at home, which is crucial for participating in online advanced courses. Only 36% of rural students reported having great internet access at home compared to 90% of their non-rural peers. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted this disparity, prompting initiatives to improve WiFi infrastructure in rural areas, thereby enhancing access to new coursework. The College Board, which administers the SAT and AP tests, now offers a plethora of free videos on each AP course subject, taught by some of the best teachers in the country. This initiative provides all students, but especially rural students, with valuable resources to supplement their learning and better prepare for advanced coursework.
While the learning aspect of teaching can be supplemented with online videos and other digital resources, the supervision and mentorship required for extracurricular activities cannot be replaced so easily. Extracurricular activities, which are crucial for holistic student development, are also adversely affected by the teacher shortage and budget constraints in rural schools. These activities, ranging from sports and arts to clubs and community service initiatives, are often limited or entirely absent in rural settings. The absence of extracurricular opportunities deprives students of chances to explore diverse interests, develop leadership skills, and build social networks that are vital for their personal growth and well-rounded education.